Five Things to Know About Long I-829 Processing Times and Abandonment of Green Card Status

Aug 6, 2020 | Investor Visas

By: Joseph Barnett, Robert Blanco, and Afshan Randera

With current Form I-829 average processing times extending beyond 3 years, it’s critical for EB-5 conditional green card holders to maintain lawful immigration status. U.S. laws provide immigration officers the right to scrutinize a green card holder’s entry upon their return from overseas to determine one’s immigration status.  Those absent from the United States for extended periods of time risk the unintentional abandonment of green card status, if a U.S. Customs and Border Patrol (“CBP”) officer determines the foreign national no longer has intent to maintain the U.S. as the principal place of residence.  Here are 5 things to know about involuntary abandonment of green card (conditional or permanent) status:

1. No Specific Time Required. We are often asked how long one must remain in the United States after obtaining a conditional green card, but there is no magic number or specific timeframe for defining or calculating abandonment of status – each situation requires an inquiry into the individual’s intentions and actions.  Sometimes green card holders believe that they can make short visits every six months or a year, but regular visits to the U.S. by a green card holder whose real residence is in another country may not protect that person.  That said, a green card holder can stay outside the country for more than 6 months/ one year and still maintain permanent resident status.  Wolfsdorf Rosenthal LLP suggests green card holders obtain a reentry permit prior to long periods of absence.

2. Intent Matters, But Facts Do Too. If a green card holder does not have the intent to permanently reside in the United States, he/she can technically lose their status, even if they visit the U.S. often. A green card holder may have multiple residences, but the U.S. residence must be the permanent one.  It is important to demonstrate that the departure from the United States was made with the intent of returning to an “unrelinquished residence,” (or that the stay abroad was for reasons beyond the foreign national’s control).  Green card holders can establish residency and show ties by keeping in regular contact with family in the U.S., even while on trips abroad; maintaining work/ work offers in the U.S.; filing taxes as a U.S. resident; maintaining financial accounts in the U.S.; renting or owning a residence; or other community ties.  Retaining supporting documentary evidence is important to demonstrate such ties.

3. Derivative EB-5 Beneficiaries. Until the permanent green card is obtained, EB-5 investors must be aware that their immigration status directly affects their dependent family members.  If the primary investor is found to have abandoned his/her status, then the dependent family members will be unable to file the Form I-829 without the investor.  Additionally, unless concluded otherwise, an alien child under the age of 16 years is not considered to possess a will or intent separate from that of the parents with regard to a protracted stay abroad.

4. Form I-407. When returning to the United States from a long trip abroad, CBP may question the reason for the length of the trip and purpose of being abroad.  If CBP deems an absence is too long or irregular , the CBP officer may judge that the green card holder has abandoned status. In some cases, they will try to make a permanent resident sign a Form I-407 “Record of Abandonment” statement declaring that he/she is voluntarily abandoning the green card.  A Form I-407 must be signed voluntarily, and there are no negative consequences for refusal to sign the form. However; in such instance, CBP must issue a Notice to Appear (NTA) before an immigration judge who will decide if permanent residence has been abandoned.

5. Application for Naturalization. Rules for maintaining green card status are separate and apart from those related to naturalization, which requires continuous residence in the United States for at least 5 years immediately preceding the date of filing Form N-400.  However, one circumstance where the U.S. government will question whether an abandonment of status has occurred is during an application for naturalization, in which a green card holder must declare and explicitly show the dates in and out of the country. If out of the country most of the time or there is irregularity, this would stand out, and the government may deny the naturalization application and even determine that you have abandoned status.

Wolfsdorf Rosenthal LLP has the expertise and experience to help an individual deemed to have involuntary abandoned his/her green card status.  Contact a Wolfsdorf Rosenthal LLP attorney with any questions about abandonment of status.

Related Posts:

EB-1 To Become Current in October 2018 Again for China and India – Is the Extraordinary Ability Visa the Best Option for Chinese Nationals?

By: Joseph Barnett Mr. Charlie Oppenheim, Chief of the Visa Control and Reporting Division within the U.S. Department of State (“DOS”), recently noted that the Final Action Date (“FAD”) for China employment-based first-preference (“EB-1”) will become current again at the beginning of Fiscal Year 2019, on October 1, 2018.  This is encouraging news, as this visa category has been subject to an FAD since April 2018 and those with approved I-140 petitions have not been able to move forward with immigrant visa processing.  Once current, visas become immediately available to those with approved I-140 petitions. U.S. immigration law offers an avenue to a green card for foreign nationals with extraordinary ability in science, arts, education, business, or athletics through sustained national or international acclaim who are coming to the U.S. to continue to work in their field of endeavor through EB-1A visa classification.  The biggest advantages of EB-1A classification are that (1) no job offer or permanent job position is required; (2) no labor certification is required; (3) self-petitions are allowed; and (4) premium processing is available for USCIS decisions within 15 days. With the China EB-5 visa backlog reaching unreasonable lengths, the EB-1A visa category has become a popular immigrant visa option […]

Expediting Immigration Applications Before USCIS

It can be frustrating to file an application or petition before U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) only to wait through seemingly endless delays. But all may not be lost: USCIS will consider requests to expedite applications and petitions on a case-by-case basis. It’s easiest and best to make an expedite request at the time of filing. Requests must meet all requirements, including documentation of a compelling reason. Keep in mind that USCIS has the sole discretion to decide whether to grant or deny a request, and the decision itself can take time. A separate option is Premium Processing Service. Both of these options are discussed below. Expedite Requests A successful expedite request might include evidence of medical need, an application that is in the U.S. national interest, or massive financial loss that may ensue if the application is delayed, for example. In cases of government error, the agency is responsible for fixing it. According to USCIS, reasons may include: Severe financial loss to a company or person, provided the need for urgent action is not the result of the petitioner’s or applicant’s failure to file the application/petition or expedite request within a “reasonable” timeframe or respond to any requests […]