Client Payment Portal

7 Years for a “Special” Form I-526 Approval

Apr 22, 2021 | Investor Visas

On April 14, 2021, U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (“USCIS”) approved our former client, Mr.  Zhang’s, Form I-526 – Immigrant Petition by Alien Entrepreneur.  His case had been pending since December 2013. 

This is a special Form I-526 approval, as Mr. Zhang was one of the two named plaintiffs in Zhang v. USCIS et al.¸ in which the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit rejected USCIS’ interpretation of the term “capital” in the EB-5 regulations.  The circuit court held that the term “cash” unambiguously includes the proceeds of third-party loans, stating “Cash is fungible, and it passes from buyer to seller without imposing on the seller any of the buyer’s obligations to his own creditors.”  The court found that USCIS’ position was inconsistent with the regulation and can thus have no legal effect.    

USCIS has not officially responded to the Zhang decision.  Mr. Zhang’s Form I-526 approval appears to confirm that USCIS will not be appealing the court’s decision to the U.S. Supreme Court for further review.

Despite the five months that have passed since the decision, USCIS’ online Policy Manual regarding the use of loan proceeds as capital has not been updated to reflect it, nor has its Class Action Member Identification Notice.  We call on USCIS to update its Policy Manual so that the court’s decision is binding on all current and future EB-5 applicants.    

Importantly, Mr. Zhang’s children may still be able to apply for conditional permanent residence due to the relief provided in the Child Status Protection Act, which allows derivative beneficiaries to subtract the amount of time a Form I-526 is pending from their age as long as they “seek to acquire” a visa within one year of approval in order to get under 21 years of age. Here the silver lining is that the 7 years, 3 months and 22 days it took to approve this petition can now be subtracted from the children’s age, potentially making them eligible for derivative immigrant status.  

While we are happy to see this result, we are saddened that it took so long for USCIS to approve the petition.  Rather than applying the plain language of the regulation, USCIS decided to add additional, unlawful requirements on the use of loans to fund an EB-5 investment.  Now that USCIS has been corrected by a federal court, it is time to modify its Policy Manual appropriately.       

Related Posts:

I-829 Processing Times Have Run Amok

USCIS is reporting online that the estimated processing time for a Form I-829 Petition by Entrepreneur to Remove Conditions on Permanent Resident Status at Immigrant Investor Program Office is now 37 to 248 months.  USCIS is only allowing case inquiries for cases filed before August 6, 2000.  This is preposterous, especially considering that USCIS is required, by regulation, to adjudicate I-829 petitions within 90 days pursuant to 8 C.F.R. § 216.6(c). More and more EB-5 investors are turning to federal courts to challenge the delays in their immigration process, including long-pending Forms I-829.  Frustrated with ongoing uncertainty about their future, as well as the repeated need to obtain proof of one’s legal status in the U.S., these conditional green card holders simply want a final resolution on their EB-5 case – for peace of mind, for naturalization purposes, and/or to receive their EB-5 investment funds back. WR Immigration has been active in assisting investors stuck in administrative limbo.  In one action against USCIS, we were able to obtain approvals and permanent green cards for all 10 immigrant investors and their derivative beneficiaries within 90 days of filing the complaint in federal court.  While past performance is no guarantee of future results, it […]

Read More

Strategies and Options for EB-5 Investors in Complex I-829 Situations

By:  Joseph Barnett The Form I-829, Petition by Investor to Remove Conditions on Permanent Resident Status (“Form I-829”) is the final step of the EB-5 process in which the immigrant investor provides evidence of one’s sustained investment and job creation.  A Form I-829 must be submitted within the 90-day period immediately preceding the second anniversary of obtaining conditional permanent resident status.  Here are five things to know about Form I-829 filings in troubling situations. 1. Regional Center Termination.  For those with conditional permanent resident status, the termination of a sponsoring Regional Center’s designation will not result in the termination of the immigrant investor’s immigration status.  The EB-5 investor can still file the Form I-829 and get adjudicated with reliance on indirect job creation. 2. Bankruptcy of Job Creating Entity.  USCIS has expressed in draft guidance that compliance with the requirement for an EB-5 immigrant investor to continuously maintain his/her capital investment over the two years of conditional residence may still be met in the event of a bankruptcy by the job creating entity.  Note, if funds were repaid to a new commercial enterprise through a creditor claim in bankruptcy, USCIS will require an investor to demonstrate redeployment of such capital during […]

Read More