Mandamus Litigation – the Solution for Unreasonably Delayed Employment and Travel Authorization Cards

Sep 18, 2020 | Investor Visas

USCIS processing times have been frustratingly long and made even worse due to COVID-19. Unfortunately, the delays are now getting longer and adversely impacting the lives of employers, employees and families. As a result, more immigrants are turning to the courts for a solution. The judicial system can provide relief when experiencing unreasonable delays for immigrant benefits – including processing an employment authorization document (EAD) and advance parole travel permits (AP) after an adjustment of status application has been filed. Depending on the facts, WR Immigration (WR) has a solution to compel USCIS to finalize adjudication within a reasonable amount of time by filing a lawsuit in federal court.

Filing a lawsuit against USCIS to adjudicate an EAD/AP has sadly become more common in other U.S. immigration contexts, such as for nonimmigrants on H-4 visas seeking work permission. The same legal theories can be applied to persons with pending adjustments including EB-5 investors with pending EADs/APs. EAD/AP applications that have been pending for well over 6 months may now be actionable.

In this process, WR attorneys prepare a complaint including information about each individual’s case and then the lawsuit is filed in federal district court.  After serving a summons and the complaint on USCIS defendants, the government has 60 days to respond to the lawsuit – by either filing an answer or challenging the lawsuit with a motion to dismiss. During this time, WR attorneys will seek to negotiate with USCIS to finalize the adjudication of each plaintiff’s EAD/AP.

We believe the USCIS delay is not due to lack of agency resources, the number of cases on file, or any provision in the law.  In most cases the delay is not justified, and a lawsuit in federal court can, in certain circumstances, push USCIS to process. WR expects demand for these cases to rise unless USCIS improves its processing times.

Contact Wolfsdorf Rosenthal LLP to obtain more information about this promising solution.

Related Posts:

I-829 Processing Times Have Run Amok

USCIS is reporting online that the estimated processing time for a Form I-829 Petition by Entrepreneur to Remove Conditions on Permanent Resident Status at Immigrant Investor Program Office is now 37 to 248 months.  USCIS is only allowing case inquiries for cases filed before August 6, 2000.  This is preposterous, especially considering that USCIS is required, by regulation, to adjudicate I-829 petitions within 90 days pursuant to 8 C.F.R. § 216.6(c). More and more EB-5 investors are turning to federal courts to challenge the delays in their immigration process, including long-pending Forms I-829.  Frustrated with ongoing uncertainty about their future, as well as the repeated need to obtain proof of one’s legal status in the U.S., these conditional green card holders simply want a final resolution on their EB-5 case – for peace of mind, for naturalization purposes, and/or to receive their EB-5 investment funds back. WR Immigration has been active in assisting investors stuck in administrative limbo.  In one action against USCIS, we were able to obtain approvals and permanent green cards for all 10 immigrant investors and their derivative beneficiaries within 90 days of filing the complaint in federal court.  While past performance is no guarantee of future results, it […]

Exclusive New EB-5 Filing Data on Rural v. High Unemployment Area Demand as of April 2024!

By Joey Barnett WR Immigration has obtained via a Freedom of Information Act request new data related to the number of Form I-526E Petitions received by Fiscal Year, Beneficiary Country of Birth, and Investment Type. This shows total filings from 2022 until  April 18, 2024.  The last similar data was from November 2023, providing an important update on the demand for EB-5.  This information will help prospective immigrant investors especially from China and India better evaluate the “hidden backlog” of pending Form I-526E cases and will also guide regional centers and EB-5 promoters where to market.     Join  WR Immigration’s Director of Visa Consulting Charlie Oppenheim and WR Partner Joey Barnett to discuss the implications of this new data during the next edition of The Bulletin – Chatting with Charlie: EB-5 Investor Outlook on September 26, 2024.  Here are five facts to know: 1. More Overall Demand for High Unemployment Area Over Rural: Through April 18, 2024, over 62% of all Form I-526Es have been in HUA.  However, in FY 2024 through April 18, 2024, that number has decreased to 53%.     2. Limited Rural Demand – Except China and India: Over 86% of all rural Form I-526Es have been […]