EB-5 I-829 Receipt Notices Extended to 24 Months, But Extensions Don’t Go Far Enough

Dec 13, 2021 | Investor Visas

With Processing 36-60 Months, Litigation May Be the Only Option to Secure Permanent Green Card

USCIS has begun to issue receipt notices to all immigrant investors with pending Form I-829, Petition by Investor to Remove Conditions on Permanent Resident Status, three months after announcing the policy change to extend Conditional Lawful Permanent Residency to 24 months upon a timely filing of a Form I-829. USCIS is issuing new receipts to immigrant investors who have already been waiting for adjudication for over 24 months, which hardly helps when the waiting line is 3-5+ years.

USCIS online processing times show that it takes the Immigrant Investor Program Office (IPO) 38 to 63.5 months to adjudicate a Form I-829.  An immigrant investor is not even allowed to inquire on the status of one’s case unless the I-829 was filed before September 2016.  This makes no sense, in particular nowadays when IPO does not have Regional Center-based Form I-526 petitions to adjudicate.

It appears USCIS will not adjudicate a Form I-829 unless being forced to as a result of mandamus litigation alleging unreasonable delay.  In the past 30 days, it appears IPO has only adjudicated 100 Form I-829s. 

For immigrant investors whose Form I-829 has been pending for more than 24 months, it is required by law to have evidence of lawful status, yet getting it is hard. One must obtain a Form I-551 ADIT stamp at a local USCIS office as evidence of lawful immigration status.  This is required for international travel and as evidence of one’s lawful ability to work in the United States.  Yet, USCIS remains reluctant to schedule Infopass appointments for I-551 stamping purposes creating headaches for immigrant investors and their family members. The law at INA 264(e) requires that permanent residents carry proof of resident status with them at  all times; in fact. It’s a Federal misdemeanor to not have ORIGINAL evidence of status, as even a photocopy is not sufficient.

As a result, many of our clients have asked us to reach out to the courts for help with unreasonable delays and the courts have been helpful.  The legal actions we file ask a Judge to order USCIS to finalize adjudication of the Form I-829 within a reasonable amount of time. These lawsuits are filed under the Administrative Procedures Act. WR Immigration has had to file numerous lawsuits against USCIS and all of the cases have been successfully resolved, either through a quick adjudication or a negotiated dismissal with USCIS that sets a schedule for USCIS to adjudicate.  In the vast majority of cases, we have gotten final resolution within 90-120 days of filing the complaint in federal court.

Please contact our EB-5 partners Vivian Zhu at vzhu@wolfsdorf.com or Joseph Barnett at jbarnett@wolfdorf.com  if you would like to join our next lawsuit.

Related Posts:

Winter 2016 U.S. Immigration Compliance Travel Advisory

by Avi Friedman and Bernard Wolfsdorf This travel advisory summarizes the main issues and requirements for foreign nationals who plan to travel outside the U.S. to make ensure reentry is as seamless as possible. If unclear, or if your specific situation needs attention, please check with your Wolfsdorf Rosenthal LLP professional prior to departure. Simply put, in order to reenter the U.S. you will need a valid immigrant visa (green card) or a valid nonimmigrant visa, or other travel document such as an advance parole travel permit, in order to be able to re-enter the U.S. Basic Documents Required Re-Entry to the U.S.: Passport valid for at least six months beyond the date of intended departure from the U.S. Valid U.S. Visa (see below, if applying for a new visa while abroad) Original Form I-797, Notice of Approval (for nonimmigrant petition based cases) and a full copy of the petition Valid Advance Parole for pending adjustment of status applicants (this must be approved prior to departure, unless you have a valid H-1B/H-4 or L-1/L-2 visa) Valid Lawful Permanent Resident Card (“Greencard”) for U.S. permanent residents. U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP) has automated Form I-94 at air and sea ports of […]

Can a Conditional Green Card Holder Marry a U.S. Citizen and Get a New Green Card in the U.S. Via Adjustment of Status When Investment Fails to Create Sufficient Jobs?

Short answer, yes. We just attended the adjustment interview while working with well-known EB-5 lawyer Tammy Fox-Isicoff to obtain an approval. In this case, the foreign national obtained conditional permanent residency through an EB-5 application that ultimately failed. Fortunately, she met a life partner, entered into a good faith marriage with her U.S. citizen husband, and intentionally did not file a Form I-829 so her immigrant status lapsed.  Since the EB-5 program involves a two-step procedure of first getting a two-year conditional green card, the applicant has a lot of pressure to ensure adequate jobs are created when submitting the I-829 application to remove the conditional nature of the green card. This application must be filed during the 90-day window preceding the 24-month anniversary of the card issuance. If the requisite number of jobs have not been created, the I-829 application will ultimately be denied, and the applicant can be placed in removal or deportation proceedings. This deadline to file a Form I-829, Petition by Investor to Remove Conditions on Permanent Resident Status causes grave concern for this group of people, and sadly, these facts are becoming more common due to the COVID-19 global pandemic and the contraction of the […]