The Immigration Brief Podcast | End of Deference? USCIS Could Reconsider Your Approval

Nov 17, 2026 | Immigration Updates

The transcript version of our podcast covering key U.S. immigration developments, policy changes, and their practical implications for employers and international talent. Join our Immigration News Digest Newsletter for more immigration updates.

By David Fullmer & Naveen Rahman Bhora

🎧 Available on YouTube & Spotify

In this edition of The Immigration Brief, WR Immigration Partners David Fullmer and Naveen Rahman Bhora discuss the Department of Homeland Security’s proposed regulation to eliminate USCIS’s deference policy for previously approved nonimmigrant visa petitions. They explain what deference means, how the policy has evolved, and what its potential removal could mean for H-1B, L-1, O-1, TN, and E visa extensions. The discussion also explores how USCIS may reassess eligibility during renewals, why prior approvals have never guaranteed future extensions, and what employers and Global Mobility teams should do to maintain strong supporting documentation and prepare for potential changes.

1: Understanding USCIS Deference and How It Works

USCIS deference is a policy under which officers generally give weight to a prior approval when reviewing an extension petition involving the same employer, employee, and position, provided there have been no material changes in circumstances.

Rather than independently reassessing every aspect of eligibility, USCIS officers generally respect the previous determination when the underlying facts and circumstances remain consistent.

However, deference does not mean automatic approval. USCIS can revisit a prior decision if the original adjudication involved material errors, incorrect facts, or questions about the individual’s eligibility.

Importantly, deference does not shift the burden of proof. The petitioner must always establish that the individual meets the requirements for the requested visa classification with every filing.

2: The History of the USCIS Deference Policy

The deference policy has evolved through several administrations, with USCIS moving back and forth between respecting prior approvals and requiring fresh eligibility determinations.

  • 2004: USCIS first introduced deference through a policy memorandum instructing officers to generally respect prior eligibility determinations involving the same parties, facts, and position.
  • 2017: During the first Trump administration, USCIS rescinded the memorandum and instructed officers to make fresh eligibility determinations.
  • 2021: During the Biden administration, USCIS restored the deference policy through the USCIS Policy Manual.
  • January 2025: The policy was formally codified in the regulations under 8 CFR § 214.1(c)(5).
  • October 2026: DHS proposed eliminating the deference regulation, potentially returning USCIS to a system where officers independently reassess eligibility during extension adjudications.

David and Naveen explain that this history demonstrates how the treatment of prior approvals has changed over time. Even when deference has been in place, it has never guaranteed approval of a subsequent petition.

3: Does Deference Apply to U.S. Consulates and CBP?

The USCIS deference policy applies specifically to petitions adjudicated by USCIS. It does not require U.S. consular officers or Customs and Border Protection (CBP) to honor previous USCIS approvals.

For example, an individual with an approved O-1 petition may still face questions from a consular officer about whether they meet the extraordinary ability requirements when applying for a visa. In some cases, a consular officer may send the petition back to USCIS for reconsideration or possible revocation.

The same distinction applies to individuals seeking admission through CBP. TN applicants and certain Canadian L-1 applicants may apply directly at a port of entry, where CBP independently evaluates their eligibility.

Similarly, when someone initially obtains a visa or status through a consulate or CBP and later files an extension with USCIS, the agency conducts its own review.

The attorneys emphasize that prior USCIS approvals have never been universally binding across the different government agencies involved in immigration adjudications.

4: Which Visa Categories Could Be Affected?

The proposed elimination of deference extends beyond H-1B petitions and could affect virtually all employer-sponsored nonimmigrant petitions adjudicated by USCIS.

These include:

  • H-1B: USCIS could reassess specialty occupation eligibility, degree requirements, job duties, and worksite information.
  • L-1A: Officers could take another look at whether the employee continues to qualify for managerial or executive capacity.
  • L-1B: USCIS could independently reassess whether the employee’s role continues to meet the specialized knowledge requirements.
  • O-1: Officers could reconsider extraordinary ability eligibility, the strength of the supporting evidence, and the individual’s continued accomplishments.
  • TN: Extensions filed through USCIS could receive a fresh eligibility review.
  • E-1 and E-2: Treaty trader and investor extensions filed through USCIS could also be affected.

David and Naveen explain that even when an employee’s position and circumstances have not changed, USCIS could independently revisit the facts supporting the original petition.

This makes it particularly important for employers to ensure that future extension applications are supported by current documentation demonstrating continued eligibility.

5: The Importance of Maintaining Current Supporting Evidence

One of the most important considerations for employers and foreign national employees is maintaining strong supporting evidence throughout the period of employment.

David and Naveen emphasize that employees should not rely exclusively on documentation submitted with their previous petition, particularly when preparing O-1 and L-1 extensions.

For O-1 beneficiaries, continuing to build a record of professional accomplishments can be especially important. This may include:

  • Continuing research and academic contributions.
  • Publishing articles and professional work.
  • Reviewing journal articles and contributing to their professional field.
  • Maintaining an updated CV or résumé.
  • Documenting professional recognition and achievements.

Naveen explains that this is particularly relevant for Ph.D. holders who transition from academic research into industry positions. Even when their day-to-day responsibilities no longer involve research, continuing to participate in academic and professional activities can help keep their supporting evidence current.

For L-1A managers and executives, employers should maintain documentation demonstrating the employee’s managerial or executive responsibilities. This may include:

  • Organizational charts.
  • Emails demonstrating managerial oversight.
  • Project plans and project documentation.
  • Work product showing executive or managerial responsibilities.
  • Records of changes in reporting structures and employee responsibilities.

USCIS may request this type of evidence when evaluating whether an individual continues to qualify for L-1A classification. Keeping these records organized throughout employment can make future extension applications much stronger.

6: Should Employers Be Concerned About the Proposed Change?

Although the proposed regulation is worth monitoring, David and Naveen do not believe employers should panic over the potential elimination of deference.

The fundamental requirement has always been that employers demonstrate an employee’s eligibility for the requested visa classification. Prior approvals have never guaranteed that future extensions will be approved, and immigration attorneys have generally prepared extension petitions as standalone cases rather than relying solely on previous approvals.

Even if deference is eliminated, the practical approach to preparing strong immigration petitions should remain largely the same.

Employers should continue working with immigration counsel to ensure that each petition contains sufficient evidence to establish eligibility, regardless of whether the employee has previously been approved in the same classification.

7: What Employers and Global Mobility Teams Should Do Now

The proposed regulation has not yet taken effect, meaning the current regulations and deference policy remain in place.

However, employers, HR professionals, and Global Mobility teams should continue monitoring developments and ensure they are prepared for potential changes.

David and Naveen emphasize several important considerations:

Monitor employee role changes: Keep track of changes in job duties, responsibilities, reporting structures, and work arrangements.

Maintain supporting documentation: Ensure evidence demonstrating continued eligibility is collected and organized throughout employment.

Prepare for future extensions: Avoid relying exclusively on evidence submitted with previous petitions.

Work with immigration counsel: Evaluate potential eligibility concerns early and identify documentation gaps before extension filings.

Stay informed: Monitor the proposed regulation and any subsequent DHS announcements to understand when or whether the changes may take effect.

Being proactive about documentation and maintaining strong supporting evidence can help employers and employees navigate future extension applications, regardless of whether the proposed regulation is ultimately implemented.

Final Takeaways

The proposed elimination of USCIS deference could mean that previously approved nonimmigrant visa petitions receive a fresh eligibility review when employees apply for extensions. However, the proposal does not change the current regulations yet, and the underlying burden of proof has always rested with the petitioner.

David and Naveen emphasize that employers should not rely solely on previous approvals when preparing future immigration filings. Instead, maintaining current supporting documentation, tracking changes in employee responsibilities, and building strong cases throughout employment will remain essential.

For employers, HR professionals, and Global Mobility teams, the key takeaway is to stay informed, work closely with immigration counsel, and ensure that every extension petition can stand on its own merits. Even if USCIS eliminates deference, strong preparation and documentation will continue to be the foundation of successful immigration filings.

About the Authors

David Fullmer is a Partner in WR Immigration’s Los Angeles office with nearly 30 years of experience advising employers, entrepreneurs, and individuals on business and investment-based immigration. He focuses on corporate immigration strategy, global mobility, and employment-based immigration, helping organizations develop practical solutions for international workforce needs. He is ranked by Chambers and Partners and previously served as Chair of the Immigration Section of the Los Angeles County Bar Association.

Naveen Rahman Bhora is a Partner at WR Immigration and manages the firm’s New York office. She advises individuals, businesses, multinational corporations, hospitals, and universities on employment-based immigration, with particular expertise in intracompany transfers, extraordinary ability visas, and immigration options for physicians and researchers. She has been recognized by Who’s Who Legal and The Best Lawyers in America® and is an active member of the American Immigration Lawyers Association (AILA).

Subscribe to the WR Immigration Newsletters

Start the RFP Process

Join the Corporate Benchmarking Roundtable

Request an Attorney Consultation

Related Posts:

2025 US Diversity Visa Lottery to Open Next Week

The Diversity Immigrant Visa Program (DIVP) is a government lottery program that offers a straightforward path to obtaining US Permanent Residence (green card). This program allocates 50,000 visas annually to applicants from countries with low rates of immigration to the United States and specific education qualifications. The registration period for...

WR Immigration News Digest

For audio listeners, you can listen to our audio version of the News Digest here. You can also join our Immigration News Digest Newsletter here. DHS Proposal to Overhaul Asylum EAD Eligibility DHS has published a proposed rule that would substantially tighten and delay employment authorization eligibility for asylum applicants....